Do you mean the FIRST TIME or the FIRST MEMORABLE TIME?
Okay, if we were talking MEMORABLE, it would be the entirety of YANNI LIVE AT THE ACROPOLIS that repeated about four times (and that cd is over 79 minutes in length!)
fIRST TIME would be "Whatever You Want" by Tony! Toni! Tone! and "Let's Chill" by Guy. . . hey, it was 1991, y'all and high school for me . . . come to think of it, Color Me Badd's "Thinkin' Back" was playin' that night too!
"Even the devil may cry when he looks around Hell and realizes that he is all alone"
Acheron Parthenopaeus
(Sherrilyn Kenyon, Devil May Cry)
http://www.wordclay.com/BookStore/BookStoreBookDetails.aspx?bookid=37784